Introduction
“The book itself has its genesis in the Crisis/Media Workshop that was jointly organized in Delhi by Sarai-CSDS, Delhi and the Waag Society, Amsterdam, a year ago in March 2003. The concept, outlined in the workshop publication by Shuddhabrata Sengupta and Geert Lovink, was a response to 9/11, the invasion of Afghanistan, the violence in Gujarat and the Kargil war. Over 3 days, participants from many different parts of South Asia and the world gathered to debate and dissect the relationship between the notion of crisis and the media, exactly one year after Gujarat had gone up in flames, and just as the ‘Coalition of the Willing’ was gearing up to bomb Baghdad. The process of editing the Reader only confirmed what we felt that the workshop had already set in motion – an unruly but very necessary set of forays into the realm of ‘the unspeakable’. Our contributors were opening out new spaces for dialogue, not only by inaugurating discussion on things that had hitherto been left unsaid, but also in the way that different elements were speaking to each other. Our task was to enable this conversation to interrupt itself, to make all sorts of unruly connections, to foster linkages between disparate truths and conflicting claims to attention…”
Production
Editorial Collective: Monica Narula, Shuddhabrata Sengupta, Ravi Sundaram, Ravi S Vasudevan, Awadhanedra Sharan, Jeebesh Bagchi (Sarai), and Geert Lovink.
Design: Renu Iyer and Monica Narula.
Read
The entire book can be accessed and downloaded from the Sarai archive.
Contents
APPROACHING CRISIS
Bearing Inconvenient Witness: Notes in Pro/Confessional Mode – Ranjit Hoskote
Peace is War: The Collateral Damage of Breaking News – Arundhati Roy
Financialization, Emotionalization and Other Ugly Concepts – Toby Miller
Interventionist Media in Times of Crisis – Soenke Zehle
Western Wars and Peace Activism: Social Movements in Global Mass-Mediated Politics – Martin Shaw
IMAGE DISTURBANCE
Let us Become Children! Training, Simulations and Kids – Kristian Lukic
What is to be Done? – Bhrigupati Singh
Disreputable and Illegal Publics: Cinematic Allegories in Times of Crisis – Ravi Vasudevan
Protesting Capitalist Globalization on Video – Oliver Ressler
Barcelona Pictures – Sasja Barentsen
From One Crisis to the Next: The Fate of Political Art in India – Nancy Adajania
On Representing the Musalman – Shahid Amin
Machines Made to Measure: On the Technologies of Identity and the Manufacture of Difference – Raqs Media Collective
CRISIS MEDIA – CASE STUDIES
Media Representations of the Kargil War and the Gujarat Riots – Subarno Chatterji
Small Town News – Taran N. Khan
‘Out of the Box’: Telelvisual Representations of North East India – Daisy Hasan
Lost in Transit: Narratives and Myths of The Crash of Egypt Air Flight 990 Crash in Egyptian and American Newspapers – Mahmoud Eid
Of Nasty pictures and “Nice Guys”: The Surreality of Online Hindutva – Christiane Brosius
Media Looking Beyond Crisis? The Urdu/Pakistani Press in New York after 9/11 – Rehan Ansari
Tried by the Media: The S.A.R. Geelani Trial – Nandita Haksar
TRUTH/TESTIMONY
“I saw it on CNN so it must be true…wrong!” – Craig Etcheson
“CNN made me do (Not Do) it”: Assessing Media Influence on US Interventions in Somalia and Rwanda – Lyn S. Graybill
Readers vs. Viewers – Ivo Skoric
Cracks in the Urban Frame: The Visual Politics of 9/11 – Ranjani Mazumdar
Truth Telling, Gujarat and the Law – Arvind Narrain
CAUTION: REPORTERS AT WORK
Massacres and the Media: A Field Reporter Looks Back on Gujarat 2002 – Darshan Desai
The Everyday Life of the Srinagar Correspondent: Reporting from Kashmir – Muzamil Jaleel
A Reporter in Prison – Iftikhar Gilani
Covering Kashmir: The Datelines of Despair – Basharat Peer
Mumbai(Dongri)-Gujarat-Mumbai-Kashmir: Pages from my Diary – Zainab Bawa
WAR CORRESPONDENCES: FIRST PERSON PLURAL
Thoughts on Afghanistan in Five Parts – Meena Nanji
On Experiencing Afghanistan – Daphne Meijer
The Afghan eXplorer: http://compcult.media.mit.edu/afghan_x/ – The Computing Culture Research Group – MIT Media Lab
Waiting: Entries from a Filmmakers Diary in and around Tel Aviv – Annabel Faroqhi
Last E-mail from the Gaza Strip – Rachel Corrie
The Guerrila News Network’s Documentaries: Interview with Stephen Marshall – Geert Lovink
Synchronicities: Baghdad/Delhi – Anand Vivek Taneja
Portrait of a Day in Baghdad – Paul Chan
Diary of a News Cameraman: Baghdad, July 2003 – Shakeb Ahmed
Rescued Pages of War Sense – Tarun Bhartiya
DEEP INSTABILITIES
Politics in the Picture: Witnessing Environmental Crises in the Media – Sanjay Kak
The Toxic Times of India: The Plastic Monster and a State of Emergency – Ravi Agarwal
Remembering SARS in Beijing: The Nationalist Appropriation of an Epidemic – Sanjay Sharma
Evictions – Projections: Watching Dharmendra in Suburban Lagos – Hansa Thapliyal
Mediated Guilt: The Illusion of Participation in Delhi’s Social Welfare Advertisements – Omar Kutty
Journey through a Disaster: A Filmmaker’s Account of the Gujarat Earthquake, 2001 – Batul Mukhtiar
CYBERMOHALLA STREET LOGS
LOG OO1, 20th October, 2003 – Dakshinpuri Cybermohalla Media Lab
INFORMATION = POLITICS
P2P: Power to the People – Janko Röttgers
War in the Age of Pirate Reproduction – Nitin Govil
Floss and the ‘Crisis’: Foreigner in a Free Land? – Martin Hardie
Introducing AIDC as a Tool for Data Surveillance – Beatriz Da Costa, Jamieson Schulte and Brooke Singer
Anagrams of Orderly Discorder (For the New Global Order) – Geoff Cox, Joasia Krysa + Adrian Ward
The Tools and Tactics of A Festival: Looking Back at N5M4 – David Garcia
The Revenge of Lowtech: Autolabs, Telecentros and Tactical Media in Sao Paulo – Ricardo Rosas
CONTESTING CENSORSHIP
Reasonable Restrictions and Unreasonable Speech – Lawrence Liang
‘The Whole Constitution Goes for Six’: Legislative Privileges and the Media – Sudhir Krishnaswamy
Censorship Myths and Imagined Harms – Shohini Ghosh
Homeless Everywhere: Writing in Exile – Taslima Nasrin
<ALT/OPTION>
Manifesto Against Labour – Gruppe Krisis